30 Aug INSURERS FACE FINANCIAL STRAIN FROM MEDICAID ENROLLMENT CHANGES
During the pandemic, Medicaid enrollment surged due to federal measures that required states to maintain coverage for individuals, even if they gained other insurance. This policy, implemented in March 2020, lasted three years and added over 23.3 million people to Medicaid, pushing the total number of beneficiaries to 95 million at its peak. Private insurers managing Medicaid plans greatly benefited from this influx, as roughly 75% of Medicaid enrollees were under their care. However, with the end of the public health emergency, states have started removing individuals from Medicaid, leading to more than 20 million people being disenrolled over the past year.
This reduction in membership has resulted in a significant drop in revenue for insurers. While the decrease in revenue was expected, the greater concern for insurers has been the shift in the demographic of remaining enrollees. As healthier individuals left Medicaid, those who remained tended to have higher healthcare costs. This unexpected trend has put pressure on insurers’ earnings, with companies like Centene, Elevance, and UnitedHealth experiencing increased Medicaid expenses this year.
In some cases, many disenrolled individuals had other coverage, including employer-sponsored plans, but were still being counted as Medicaid members. Some were even unaware of their continued Medicaid enrollment during the pandemic, further inflating the numbers of people who weren’t utilizing Medicaid services, yet still generating payments for insurers. This dynamic created a windfall for insurance companies, who were receiving funds from states for members who didn’t access care.
The impact of these changes is being felt in the stock market. For instance, Elevance’s shares dropped when the company projected higher Medicaid costs in the latter half of the year. Molina, on the other hand, experienced a positive trading response after reporting earnings that offset Medicaid-related pressures with other financial gains.
Medicaid businesses already operate on thin profit margins, and higher utilization rates exacerbate their financial challenges. Though insurers are working to secure better rates from states to account for rising costs, the process is slow due to the decentralized nature of Medicaid, where each state determines rates individually. While eventual rate adjustments are expected to alleviate some of the pressure, the road ahead for Medicaid insurers remains uncertain and challenging as they navigate this transitional Medicaid enrollment period. In order to preserve program resources, insurers must look to innovative ways to increase efficiency and reduce costs.